19 November 2026
    · By Jessica Wright

    The Milburn report and the goal of ‘NEET Zero’

    Five months on from his initial report examining the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), former Labour Health Secretary Alan Milburn has this week finally published his full recommendations. Titled “From a Welfare State to a Working State”, the report sets out a sweeping programme of reforms across education, employment, health and benefits.

    A legal guarantee and Youth Opportunity Service 

    At its heart, the review sets out a “radical blueprint” designed to offer young people a path into “work not welfare”. It proposes legal guarantees that would give every young person not in education, employment or training a pathway into work, education or training, regardless of whether they claim benefits. This would include the health, employment and practical support needed to pursue it, following the example set by the Netherlands, which has a similar legal framework, and in 2025 reported a NEET rate of just 4.8%. 

    This mission would be overseen by the Youth Opportunity Service, which will report directly to Andy Burnham, but keeping with the true ethos of the PM, the development and rollout of the Youth Opportunity Service will be devolved to a local level. By 2029 there would be a Youth Opportunity Service in every area of England, commissioned by mayors, with a named adviser within 14 days and an action plan within four weeks. Anyone still NEET after 12 months despite engaging would be offered a paid six-month job. 

    Apprenticeships: aiming to rival university 

    Exciting for both NEETs and business is the focus this report placed on apprenticeships, as they are hailed as the best route from training to skilled employment. The number of NEETs completing one would double over the decade, with around 35 per cent of each cohort starting one by 25 and 270,000 under-25 starts a year by 2036. The goal is for apprenticeships to rival universities as the next step for school leavers. Modelling suggests 500,000 extra opportunities are needed, and the reforms should help around 440,000 young people into sustained work.

    A single Youth Allowance and a “duty to engage” 

    The most contentious change is welfare. For under-25s, a single Youth Allowance would replace the Universal Credit health top-up, and PIP would give way to a targeted Additional Cost Allowance. Young people would sign up to a “duty to engage”, and persistent refusal could ultimately mean losing the allowance, though sanctions should be “rare”. Milburn, unlike Burnham at this stage, admits it will not be pain-free. Some would get less support in the short-term, but the long-term gain of employment and a wage would be worth it.

    Now for the bit the opposition cannot wait to get their teeth into – how much will this cost the taxpayer? 

    The bill will be front-loaded: £500m in 2027-28, rising to £5.8bn a year by 2036-37. By 2037 this will be offset by £3.6bn in welfare savings and £2.4bn in extra tax revenue and lower benefit spending. The initial funding for this, the PM has advised, will be found through cuts to government departments, though the details of which will need some thrashing out nearer the time. This review proposes a major overhaul of spending on NEETs. Currently, for every £1 spent on helping young people into work, £25 is spent on benefits; the Milburn review aims to shift that ratio significantly to £1 to £2.

    A cautious Government, a critical opposition 

    The government has been careful. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told the Commons that a new unit will respond to the recommendations, with a welfare white paper to follow in the new year. Burnham has stopped short of promising to accept everything in the report.

    The report has, so far, garnered broad support from Labour MPs, perhaps benefiting from some of the key rebels of the 2025 welfare reforms now holding key roles in government. The framing of this report has very much focused on the moral issue of continual youth unemployment, with 2025 welfare rebel Debbie Abrahams stating in parliament that these recommendations will create “an opportunity of a generation”. This suggests Labour has learnt some key lessons after 2025, framing the argument for welfare cuts as a moral one, engaging with MPs, and briefing out key details to the media in advance to avoid major shocks. This could act as a ‘NEET’ blueprint (if you pardon the pun) for Burnham when future tough calls come down the line.

    The opposition response has been largely predictable. Shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions Helen Whately couldn’t resist pointing the finger at Labour’s tax rises and employment law changes, saying the report “trashed” the government’s economic decisions, and warned of “a massive expansion in the size and responsibilities of the state“. Liberal Democrat Leader Sir Ed Davey argued that no target can “conjure up jobs that don’t exist” and called for scrapping Labour’s “jobs tax”, while Reform’s Suella Braverman called the push to cut hiring costs “a glaring admission that Labour’s jobs tax has failed“.

    What’s in it for employers

    The government has asked employers to create more genuine first jobs, more youth apprenticeships and much wider access to meaningful work experience. In return, the government will offer simplified incentives to do so, cash payments, and lower NI costs, in addition to a one-stop shop for all their future NEET hiring needs in the form of their local Youth Opportunity Services.

    The Youth Jobs Grant would pay £3,000 for taking on someone who has been NEET for six months, plus £2,000 for those facing greater barriers, and £2,000 for firms with fewer than 50 staff – up to £7,000 in all. Part of this cash is held back to reward retention, though when businesses qualify for this is yet to be confirmed. The package costs around £1.1bn a year at scale, doubling current spending, and should create 170,000 extra jobs and apprenticeships. 

    NI incentives for businesses would begin in the retail and hospitality industries, by doubling the thresholds for employers to begin contributing to NI from £5,000 to £10,000 for 21-24 year olds over a five-year period. The intention will be to spread this incentive further than just retail and hospitality in time, but as they hire over a third of 16-24 year olds this will be the priority.

    What happens next

    The new Youth Opportunities Unit, conveniently chaired by Mr Milburn, will now lead efforts to coordinate the government’s response and drive implementation. With the white paper expected early next year and Andy Burnham’s ten-year plan due in December, the policy landscape could shift significantly over the coming months. Businesses should engage early to help shape how the government adopts and implements these recommendations.

    If you or your organisation wants to influence the skills or wider business agenda, get in touch with College Green Group. Our expert insight into policy developments and strategic advice can help you to shape the debate and position your organisation for success.

    More insights